This content tells the extraordinary and tragic story of James Armistad Lafayette, an enslaved man who became a crucial spy for the Continental Army during the American Revolution, directly contributing to the victory at Yorktown, yet was largely erased from historical narratives and denied freedom for years.
Mind Map
Click to expand
Click to explore the full interactive mind map • Zoom, pan, and navigate
There are secrets that win wars and
there are men who carry those secrets
invisible to history whose names
dissolve into silence even as their
actions changed the world. This is the
story of one such man, a slave who
walked between armies who whispered in
the ears of generals who held the fate
of a nation in his hands while wearing
chains on his wrists. His intelligence
decided the outcome of the American
Revolution. Yet when victory came, when
cannons fell silent and treaties were
signed, his name was nowhere to be
found. He died as he had lived,
invisible, forgotten, erased. But the
truth, as it always does, remained
buried in documents waiting to be
uncovered. And the truth is darker, more
dangerous, and more extraordinary than
anyone could imagine. This is not a
story of heroes. This is a story about a
man who changed history and then watched
history forget him. The plantation
stretched across New Kent County like a
kingdom of tobacco and suffering. 300
acres of Virginia soil worked by 63
human beings who were legally classified
as property. The main house stood white
and columnmed, a monument to prosperity
built on the backs of people who would
never own anything, not even themselves.
James had been born there in 1760,
though no one recorded the exact date.
Slave births were noted in ledgers the
way livestock births were noted. A
simple entry, a name if you were
fortunate, a gender, a potential future
value. His mother had been a house
servant named Ruth. His father a field
worker whose name James never learned
because he was sold to a plantation in
South Carolina before James could form
memories. Ruth raised him with the
particular kind of careful love that
enslaved mothers developed, fierce but
tempered, protective but realistic. She
taught him early that survival meant
understanding the unspoken rules of the
plantation world. Never look a white
person directly in the eyes for too
long. Never show anger no matter what
was done to you. Never reveal what you
were thinking. Your face, your body
language, your very posture had to
communicate submission even when your
mind screamed rebellion. You got a mind,
baby, Ruth whispered to him when he was
perhaps 7 years old, holding him close
in the dark of their cabin. A good mind,
sharp, but you can't never let them see
it. A slave with a mind is dangerous to
them. You keep that mind hidden. You
hear me? You keep it locked up tight and
maybe someday it saves your life. James
learned to watch. The plantation was a
complex social ecosystem and
understanding its dynamics meant the
difference between relative safety and
sudden violence. He learned which
overseers were merely cruel and which
were sadistic. He learned which house
servants had the master's ear and which
could be trusted. He learned to read the
weather patterns of William Armistad's
moods, when the master was generous,
when he was angry, when he was drunk and
dangerous. William Armistad was not the
worst master in Virginia, which was a
low bar to clear. He beat his slaves
rarely, fed them adequately, and
occasionally expressed vague discomfort
with the institution of slavery while
continuing to profit from it. He
considered himself an enlightened man, a
reader of philosophy, a believer in the
natural rights of mankind, at least in
the abstract. The contradiction between
his stated beliefs and his daily
practice never seemed to trouble him
deeply. The plantation operated with
mechanical efficiency. Dawn brought the
bells that woke the enslaved population.
Breakfast was cornmeal mush, sometimes
with a bit of salt pork if you were
fortunate. Then the fields, endless
tobacco plants that needed constant
attention. Planting season, growing
season, harvesting season, curing
season. The cycle repeated itself with
agricultural certainty, and James'
childhood disappeared into that cycle
year after year. But James was different
in ways that even he didn't fully
understand yet. While other children
played during their brief moments of
free time, James observed. He watched
how the overseers organized work details
and learned to anticipate their
commands. He listened when house
servants gossiped about the master's
business dealings and began to
understand economics. He paid attention
when traveling merchants visited the
plantation and absorbed information
about the wider world beyond New Kent
County. He couldn't read. Teaching
slaves to read was illegal in Virginia,
punishable by fines or worse. But he
developed a different kind of literacy.
He learned to read people, to understand
what they wanted before they spoke it,
to anticipate needs and fulfill them
before being asked. This made him
valuable, which made him relatively
safe. By the time James reached his
teenage years, he had been promoted from
pure fieldwork to more complex tasks. He
worked in the stables, caring for the
master's horses. He helped maintain
equipment, demonstrating an intuitive
mechanical understanding. He ran errands
to neighboring plantations, proving
himself trustworthy enough to be allowed
limited freedom of movement. And all the
while, he watched, listened, remembered
everything. The whispers of revolution
began reaching the plantation in the
early 1770s.
Travelers brought newspapers. House
servants overheard dinner conversations
about something called the Stamp Act.
the Towns Hends, mounting tensions with
Parliament. James absorbed these
fragments of information, piecing
together a picture of growing colonial
discontent. In 1775,
fighting broke out in Massachusetts,
Lexington, and Concord became names that
echoed through Virginia. The Continental
Congress in Philadelphia declared
independence in July 1776.
And suddenly, Virginia's plantation
aristocracy found itself leading a
revolutionary war while simultaneously
maintaining a system of human bondage.
The irony was not lost on the enslaved
population. White men spoke passionately
about liberty, natural rights, and
freedom from tyranny while keeping other
human beings in chains. The
contradiction was glaring, absurd, and
deeply revealing. But James understood
something that more radical slaves
sometimes didn't. Contradictions created
opportunities. A society at war with
itself, fighting for principles it
didn't fully practice, was a society in
flux. And in that flux, a clever person
might find room to maneuver. When
British armies invaded Virginia in 1779,
the plantation world began to fracture.
British commanders seeking to
destabilize the colonial economy and
weaken revolutionary resolve issued
proclamations offering freedom to any
slave who abandoned their rebel masters
and joined the king's forces. Thousands
accepted the offer, fleeing plantations
and running toward British lines. The
plantation population on the Armistad
estate dropped from 63 to 41 in a matter
of months. William Armistad fumed about
British treachery and the ingratitude of
slaves. He increased security, hired
additional overseers, and made examples
of anyone caught planning escape. James
watched the runaways go with mixed
feelings. Part of him wanted to join
them, to run toward the promise of
British freedom, but another part, the
part that watched and calculated,
wondered if that promise was genuine.
The British were offering freedom as a
military strategy, not out of moral conviction.
conviction.
What would happen to those formerly
enslaved people when the war ended?
Would they truly be free, or would they
simply be used and discarded? He didn't
know, but he filed the information away,
understanding that this moment of
historical chaos might present
opportunities he couldn't yet imagine.
In early 1781, the war came directly to
New Kent County. British forces under
the traitor Benedict Arnold raided
through Virginia, burning and looting.
They were followed by Continental Army
forces trying desperately to contain the
damage. The plantation became a way
point in a military campaign, hosting
soldiers from both sides at different
times. And that's when James met the man
who would change his life. Mar Joseph
Paul Eve Ro Gilbert Dumoteier Marque de
Lafayette was 23 years old and
approximately as idealistic as a human
being could be without actually floating
off the ground. He was tall, red-haired,
awkward in a particularly aristocratic
way and absolutely convinced that the
American cause was the most righteous
endeavor in human history. He had
arrived in America 4 years earlier, a
teenager with more noble blood than
practical military experience,
determined to fight for liberty. General
George Washington had initially regarded
him as a wealthy nuisance, another
European aristocrat playing at war. But
Lafayette proved himself through genuine
courage, tactical intelligence, and an
almost reckless willingness to put
himself in danger. Washington came to
regard him almost as a son. By spring
1781, Lafayette commanded Continental
forces in Virginia with orders to
contain British operations until
reinforcements could arrive. He was
outnumbered, undersupplied, and facing
some of Britain's most experienced
commanders. His army consisted of barely
3,000 men, many of them inexperienced
militia. Discipline was inconsistent,
supplies were scarce, and morale
fluctuated between determined and
desperate. What Lafayette needed more
than anything was intelligence. In war,
information was as valuable as
ammunition. He needed to know where
British forces were positioned, where
they were going, what their supply
situations looked like, what their
commanders were planning. Without
accurate intelligence, he was fighting
blind. The problem was that conventional
reconnaissance was nearly impossible.
British forces controlled most of the
territory and any Continental scout
risked immediate capture. Loyalist
civilians reported suspicious activity
to British commanders, making it
difficult for rebel spies to operate
effectively. Lafayette understood
something that many of his fellow
officers, particularly those from
aristocratic European backgrounds,
struggled to grasp, that the people most
invisible in American society, could
become the most effective intelligence gatherers.
gatherers.
Enslaved Africans moved through the
landscape like furniture, seen but not
truly observed, present but not counted
as significant.
A slave moving between plantations
attracted no attention. A slave
approaching British lines with a story
about seeking freedom was expected, even
encouraged. Lafayette had employed black
spies before with remarkable success. He
trusted them more than he trusted many
of his white officers, recognizing that
they had genuine motivation, personal
freedom, revenge against the system that
enslaved them rather than abstract
political principles. When his forces
established a temporary encampment near
the Armistad plantation in late March 1781,
1781,
Lafayette made a point of meeting with
the plantation owner. William
Armiststead received the young French
general with the careful hospitality
that Virginia aristocrats extended to
those of equivalent social status, even
revolutionary ones. They dined in the
plantation house, Lafayette, Armistad,
and several Continental offices. The
conversation ranged across military
strategy, political philosophy, and the
peculiar contradictions of a revolution
for liberty being fought by
slaveholders. Lafayette, with
characteristic European directness,
questioned how Americans could speak of
natural rights while maintaining slavery.
slavery.
Armistad offered the standard Virginia
responses. Slavery was inherited, not
chosen. It was economically necessary.
It would gradually fade away as society
evolved. Many masters treated their
slaves humanely. The rationalizations
flowed smoothly, polished by repetition.
Lafayette wasn't convinced, but he was
pragmatic. He needed resources more than
he needed ideological purity, and he
needed intelligent sources. I understand
you have an enslaved man named James,
Lafayette said, shifting the
conversation. I'm told he's intelligent.
trustworthy and familiar with the
surrounding territory. Armistad nodded
cautiously. Yes, he's been with the
plantation his entire life. Capable
worker. I'd like to speak with him about
a matter of some importance to the
continental cause. What followed was a
negotiation framed as a patriotic
discussion. Armistad was reluctant to
risk valuable property, but eager to
demonstrate his revolutionary
credentials. Lafayette suggested that
James' service might reflect well on the
Armistad family, perhaps even result in
favorable consideration when the new
government distributed lands and honors
after independence was secured. The
unspoken understanding was clear.
Armistad would loan his slave to the
Continental Army for intelligence work,
and in return would gain political
capital and potential future advantages.
James himself was not part of this
negotiation. He was informed of the
decision after it had been made, told to
report to Lafayette's tent the following
morning. He spent that night lying awake
in his cabin, understanding that his
life was about to change in ways he
couldn't predict. His mother had died 2
years earlier from fever, and he had no
wife or children yet. Nothing tying him
emotionally to the plantation beyond the
general familiarity of routine. Part of
him was terrified. Another part was
curious, even excited. This was the
opportunity he had unconsciously been
waiting for.
The morning came gray and cool, the
early spring air still carrying winter's
edge. James walked to the continental
encampment with the careful posture he
had perfected over a lifetime,
subservient, but not cringing,
respectful, but not graveling. He was 20
years old, though he looked older. hard
laboraged people quickly. Lafayette
received him in a tent that smelled of
canvas, gun oil, and the peculiar
mustustininess of military equipment
stored in damp conditions. The French
general sat behind a camp desk covered
with maps and correspondence. He
gestured for James to sit, which was
surprising. Masters rarely invited
slaves to sit in their presence. James
remained standing.
I'll stand, sir, if it's all the same.
Lafayette studied him with aristocratic
curiosity, the way a natural scientist
might examine an interesting specimen.
But there was something else in his
gaze, too. A genuine interest, a
recognition of personhood that James
rarely encountered. "Your master tells
me you're intelligent and capable of
discretion," Lafayette began, his French
accent softening the harsh edges of
English. I need to determine if that
assessment is accurate. I do what I'm
told, sir, and I don't talk about it
after. That's a start. But what I need
is more complicated than simple obedience.
obedience.
Lafayette leaned forward. I need someone
who can think independently, who can
make decisions in dangerous
circumstances, who can remember complex
information without writing it down.
Someone who can lie convincingly to
people who will kill them if the lie is
detected. James felt his heartbeat
accelerate but kept his face neutral.
Sounds dangerous, sir. Extremely. You
would go into British camps pretending
to be a runaway seeking freedom under
their proclamations. You would work for
them, serve them, gain their trust, and
you would observe everything. troop
strengths, fortification positions,
supply situations, officer
conversations, strategic discussions.
You would memorize these observations
and report them back to me through a
network of contacts. And if they catch
me, they will hang you. Spies are not
afforded prisoner of war status. There
will be no trial, no exchange, no mercy.
Lafayette's voice was matterof fact, not
cruel, but honest. I will not lie to you
about the risks. James absorbed this.
his mind working through implications.
And if I refuse, then you return to your
master and continue your life as it has
been. I will not force you into this."
Lafayette paused. "Though I should
mention that your master has already
agreed to your service. Refusing me
might create difficulties with him." So,
it was a choice that wasn't really a
choice. The story of James's entire
life. He could volunteer for this
dangerous mission or face his master's
anger for refusing to support the
revolutionary cause. But Lafayette's
honesty about the dangers, his
directness about the lack of real choice
was more respectful than the usual
pretense. If I do this, James said
carefully, and we win the war, will I be
free? Lafayette's expression became complicated.
complicated.
I don't have the legal authority to free
you. That's your master's decision or
the legislaturator's. But I will
personally advocate for your freedom. I
will document your service, testify to
your contributions, and use whatever
influence I possess. But you can't
promise. No, I cannot promise. At least
it was honest. James had lived long
enough to know that white men's promises
to black people were usually worthless.
But Lafayette's refusal to make
guarantees he couldn't keep was in its
own way more trustworthy than easy
asurances would have been. James thought
about his mother's advice. Keep your
mind hidden. Use it to survive. This was
a chance to use his mind for something
more than mere survival. To be part of
something significant, even if his
contribution would never be
acknowledged. I'll do it, he said.
Lafayette nodded. something like respect
showing in his eyes. Then we have much
to discuss. Sit down, James. We need to
prepare you and we don't have much time.
The next 5 days transformed James from a
plantation slave into a covert
operative. Lafayette assigned him to a
continental intelligence officer named
Captain Benjamin Haynes, a lean Pennian
with eyes that seemed to catalog
everything and a manner that suggested
he trusted no one fully. Haynes had run
intelligence operations throughout the
war. He understood the mechanics of
espionage, the practical details that
meant the difference between successful
intelligence gathering and execution.
They worked in a small tent on the
encampment's perimeter, away from casual observation.
observation.
Haynes began with fundamentals. First
rule, you are always performing. From
the moment you approach British lines
until the moment you return to ours, you
are playing a character. That character
is not you. It's a version of you.
Simplified, less intelligent than you
actually are, more grateful for British
attention, more eager to please. You
understand? James nodded. Make myself
seem harmless. Exactly. The British
expect runaway slaves to be desperate,
grateful, and simple. Give them what
they expect. Never let them see you
thinking too hard, analyzing too
carefully. You're not stupid. That would
be suspicious, but you're not clever
either. You're competent enough to
follow orders and do basic work, but not
someone who would understand military
strategy or remember detailed
information. They practiced conversation
scenarios. Haynes would play a British
officer, questioning James about his
background, his reasons for running, his
knowledge of the area. James learned to
answer in ways that seemed spontaneous,
but were actually carefully crafted,
mixing truth with strategic omissions,
providing useful information about the
local area without revealing too much
intelligence. Where are you from?
Armistad Plantation, sir, in New Kent
County. Master William Armistad, why did
you run? Master was talking about
selling some of us to pay debts, sir. I
heard the British would give freedom to
folks who came over. Figured I'd rather
take my chances with that than get sold
to some Georgia plantation.
You know the roads around here? Yes,
sir. Run errands between plantations
before. Know the main roads, some of the
smaller paths. You ever see continental
soldiers in the area? Sometimes, sir?
They came through a few weeks back. Took
some supplies from the plantations.
Master was angry about it. It sounded
natural, unrehearsed.
That was the key. sounding spontaneous
while actually following a script,
providing information that seemed
helpful, but was actually designed to
build credibility without revealing
anything truly valuable. Haynes taught
him memory techniques, how to organize
observations mentally so they could be
recalled accurately later, how to count
large groups without obviously counting,
how to estimate distances, assess
fortification strength, identify
different types of artillery by their
appearance. You can't write anything
down. Haynes emphasized written notes or
evidence that will get you killed.
Everything has to be in your head. When
you observe something important,
mentally file it away with associated
details. If you see a supply wagon
arriving, note the time of day, what was
being unloaded, how many men were
unloading it, where it came from. If you
overhear conversation, they practiced
with camp observations. Haynes would
walk James through the continental
encampment, then quiz him hours later
about what he had seen, how many tents
in the medical area, what types of
weapons were being cleaned in the armory
section, how many horses in the cavalry
pick it. At first, James struggled to
retain the volume of detail, but his
mind adapted quickly. He developed
systems associating information with
physical locations, creating mental
images that encoded multiple data
points, organizing observations into
categories that made recall easier. By
the third day, he was retaining
information with impressive accuracy.
Haynes tested him with increasingly
complex scenarios, introducing
distractions and interruptions,
simulating the confusion of real
intelligence gathering. British officer
asks you a question while you're hauling
supplies and you're tired and
distracted. You have to answer
immediately without seeming to think too hard.
hard.
Practice. They also prepared his cover
story in exhaustive detail. Every
element had to be consistent, memorable,
and impossible to easily verify. James
would claim to have run from the
Armistad plantation seeking British
freedom. His knowledge of the
plantation, the area, and local
conditions was genuine. that couldn't be
faked. But they crafted specific details
about his alleged treatment, his
motivations, his hopes for British
freedom that would make him seem genuine
to enemy interrogators. They might test
you, Haynes warned. British intelligence
officers are not fools. They'll ask you
questions designed to catch
inconsistencies. They'll bring you back
hours or days later and ask the same
questions slightly differently to see if
your story changes. You need to be able
to maintain your cover under pressure.
They practiced interrogation scenarios.
Haynes would pepper James with
questions, circle back to previous
topics, try to catch him in
contradictions. It was exhausting,
mentally demanding in ways that physical
labor never had been. But James
discovered something about himself
during this training. He was good at
this. years of reading white people's
moods, of anticipating their
expectations, of concealing his true
thoughts behind a mask of submission.
All of that had been training for
exactly this kind of work. He had been
preparing for espionage his entire life
without knowing it. On the fourth day,
Lafayette joined them to assess James's
readiness. The French general questioned
him about his cover story, tested his
memory retention, probed for
psychological readiness. "Are you
afraid?" Lafayette asked bluntly. "Yes,
sir." "Good. Fear keeps you careful.
Overconfidence gets spies killed."
Lafayette paused. "Are you committed to
this? I need to know you won't lose your
nerve when you're inside British lines
with no way out." James met his eyes
directly, breaking the usual slave
protocol. I spent 20 years as property,
sir. I've been afraid every day of my
life. This is just a different kind of
fear, and at least this time I choose to
face it. Lafayette nodded slowly.
Captain Haynes, is he ready? Haynes
considered the question carefully. As
ready as anyone can be for this. He's
smart. He's careful. He's motivated.
Whether he can actually pull it off
under real conditions, he shrugged. We
won't know until he tries. Then we
proceed, Lafayette decided. James,
you'll leave tomorrow at first light.
Captain Haynes will brief you on your
contact network and exfiltration
procedures. Once you cross into British
territory, you're on your own. We cannot
help you if things go wrong. That night,
James lay awake in a tent provided by
the Continental Army, staring at canvas
and wondering if he was about to make
the biggest mistake of his life. He
thought about his mother, about her
advice to keep his mind hidden. He was
about to do the opposite, to use his
mind as a weapon, to risk everything on
his ability to think clearly under
impossible pressure. But he had made his
choice. And in the morning, he would
become someone else entirely. The road
to Portsmouth stretched through Virginia
countryside that looked deceptively
peaceful. Spring was asserting itself,
trees budding, wild flowers emerging,
birds returning from southern migrations.
migrations.
If you didn't look too closely at the
burned plantations and abandoned farms,
you could almost forget there was a war.
James walked alone, carrying nothing
except the clothes on his back and a
story in his head. Captain Haynes had
given him final instructions that
morning. Approach British pickets near
Portsmouth. Present himself as a
runaway. Stick to the prepared cover
story and wait for opportunities to
gather intelligence. Don't try to learn
everything at once. Haynes had warned,
"Establish yourself first. Gain trust.
Blend in. Intelligence gathering is
patient work." The walk took most of the
day. James passed other travelers on the
road, refugees fleeing the fighting,
farmers trying to maintain some
semblance of normal life, occasional
military patrols. He drew little
attention. A young black man walking
alone wasn't unusual in 1781 Virginia.
Enslaved people ran errands, carried
messages, moved between plantations.
As long as he didn't act suspicious,
most people would ignore him. Late
afternoon brought him to the British
perimeter. Portsmouth had been occupied
for weeks, transformed into a fortified
military base. Earthworks and palisades
surrounded the town. Centuries manned
checkpoints on all approach roads. The
red coats of British regulars were
visible everywhere along with the blue
and green coats of Hessian mercenaries
and the varied dress of loyalist
militia. James approached a checkpoint
with his heart hammering, but his face
carefully arranged in an expression of
nervous hope.
Two British soldiers stood guard,
experienced regulars with the weathered
look of men who had been campaigning for years.
years.
Stop there, one of them commanded. State
your business.
James stopped, adopting a posture of submission.
submission.
I'm seeking to join his majesty's
forces, sir. I'm a runaway from a rebel
plantation. I heard the British would
give freedom to slaves who come over.
The soldiers exchanged glances. They had
clearly processed dozens of similar
arrivals. Another one, the first soldier
muttered. To James, where you from?
Armistad Plantation, New Kent County,
sir. Why now? Why not run earlier?
Master was talking about selling some of
us to cover debt, sir. I figured I'd
rather take my chances with British
freedom than end up on some Georgia
plantation where they work you to death.
One soldier nodded. The explanation was
believable, common. You got skills. Can
you work? Fieldwork, sir. Strong back. I
can handle horses, do basic carpentry,
follow orders. I'm a good worker. Can
you read? No, sir.
Good. The soldier gestured toward the
town. Report to the quartermasters's
depot inside the main gates. They'll
process you, assign you work. You cause
trouble, you'll regret it. You work
hard, you'll get fed and have a chance
at freedom when this is over. Understood?
Understood?
Yes, sir. Thank you, sir. The soldiers
waved him through, already losing
interest. James walked through the
checkpoint, and just like that, he was
inside British lines. Portsmouth was a
chaotic military city. Thousands of
soldiers from multiple armies, British
regulars, German mercenaries, loyalist
Americans occupied every available
space. Warehouses had been converted to
barracks. Private homes housed officers.
Enslaved people who had fled to British
lines, performed labor throughout the
town, unloading supply ships at the
docks, constructing fortifications,
cooking, cleaning, maintaining
equipment. James found the quarterm's
depot, a large warehouse buzzing with
activity. A harried sergeant processed
new arrivals with bureaucratic
efficiency. James waited in line behind
three other recently arrived runaways,
listening to their stories. Most were
similar to his own. People fleeing harsh
conditions, seeking the freedom that
British proclamations promised. When his
turn came, the sergeant asked peruncter
questions while filling out a form.
Name: James, sir? Last name? Just James,
sir. Slaves don't have last names
mostly. Previous master, William
Armistad, New Kent County. skills,
fieldwork, basic carpentry, horse
handling, literacy? No, sir. The
sergeant nodded, made notations,
assigned James a number for tracking
purposes. You'll work with construction
crews reinforcing fortifications. Report
to Sergeant Welsh at the North
Earthworks tomorrow morning at dawn.
You'll be housed in the laborer's
quarters near the docks. Any questions?
No, sir. Thank you, sir. Next. And that
was it. James had infiltrated British
headquarters with nothing more than a
plausible story and a submissive
demeanor. No one suspected him because
why would they? He was exactly what he
appeared to be, another escaped slave
seeking British freedom, grateful and
compliant. The laborer's quarters were a
converted tobacco warehouse now housing
roughly 200 black men and women who had
fled to British lines. Crude bunks lined
the walls. The air smelled of too many
humans in too little space, but compared
to slave cabins on plantations, it was
actually somewhat better. The British
fed their workers adequately,
understanding that labor required fuel.
James found an empty bunk and settled
in, listening to conversations around
him. People shared their stories, where
they had come from, what they had fled,
their hopes for the future. Some were
optimistic, believing British promises
of freedom. Others were more cynical,
suspecting they had simply traded one
form of bondage for another. A man in
the next bunk introduced himself as
Samuel, originally from a plantation
near Williamsburg. He had been with the
British for 2 months. They treat you
decent mostly, Samuel said. Works hard,
but they feed you regular, and the
overseers don't beat you like plantation
overseers do. Some of the officers are
bastards, but some are actually
respectful. It's strange, you know,
being called by your name, not just boy
or worse. "You think they'll really give
us freedom?" James asked, playing his
role as a naive newcomer," Samuel
shrugged. "I think they'll give us
freedom as long as it helps them win the
war." "What happens after?" "I don't
know, but it's got to be better than
what we left behind." James filed the
information away. the attitudes of other
runaways, their levels of trust in
British promises, their observations
about how the occupation worked. Every
piece of information was potentially
valuable. That night, lying in the dark
warehouse, listening to the sounds of
hundreds of people sleeping, coughing,
shifting. James allowed himself to
acknowledge the fear he had been
suppressing all day.
He was deep inside enemy territory now,
surrounded by soldiers who would kill
him without hesitation if they
discovered his true purpose. But he had
made it through the first day. His cover
was established.
Now the real work would begin. The next
6 weeks were the most intense education
of James's life. He worked construction
during the day, hauling materials,
digging trenches, reinforcing
earthworks, while observing everything
with the careful attention Captain
Haynes had trained into him. He learned
the rhythm of the British military
machine. Morning formations at dawn with
drums calling soldiers to attention,
breakfast routines that varied by unit.
British regulars received better rations
than loyalist militia. Hesshen
mercenaries had their own supply
systems. Work details organized by type,
construction crews, dock workers,
maintenance teams, evening formations,
guard rotations, nighttime security
protocols. He memorized the layout of
Portsmouth's fortifications, mentally
mapping defensive positions, counting
artillery pieces, noting fields of fire,
and vulnerable approaches. The British
were building Portsmouth into a
fortress, clearly intending to hold it
as a permanent base for operations in
Virginia. Supply ships arrived regularly
from New York, unloading equipment,
ammunition, food, replacement soldiers.
James worked dock details frequently,
giving him opportunities to observe what
was being delivered and in what
quantities. A sudden increase in
artillery ammunition suggested
preparations for a campaign. medical
supplies arriving in bulk might indicate
expectations of casualties. Every detail
told part of a larger story, but the
most valuable intelligence came from
simply listening. British soldiers
talked freely around enslaved laborers,
not considering that these simple
workers might understand the
significance of what was being
discussed. Officers conversed in front
of James as if he were furniture,
discussing troop movement, supply
problems, strategic frustrations. He
heard complaints about ammunition
shortages, discussions about tensions
between British regulars and Hessen
mercenaries, speculation about when Lord
Cornwallis would arrive to take supreme
command in Virginia, frustration that
the Royal Navy couldn't adequately
patrol all of Virginia's waterways
against continental harassment. Every
conversation was a piece of
intelligence. James filed them all away
in his carefully organized mental
catalog, waiting for the opportunity to
report. The contact system Captain
Haynes had established was ingenious in
its simplicity. Every week, James would
volunteer for work details that took him
outside Portsmouth's immediate
fortifications, collecting firewood,
foraging supplies, delivering messages
to outlying pickets. During these
excursions, he would make brief contact
with continental sympathizers who moved
through the countryside as farmers,
traders, or travelers. The contacts
changed regularly to avoid establishing
patterns. One week it might be a free
black man operating a small farm who
would engage James in casual
conversation while passing along a
pre-arranged signal. The next week, a
white farmer's wife buying supplies at a
market where James' work detail happened
to stop.
Each contact had been carefully vetted
by Continental intelligence. Each knew
only enough to fulfill their specific
role. James would deliver his
intelligence verbally, speaking quickly
and precisely while maintaining the
appearance of casual conversation.
The contact would memorize the
information or in some cases discreetly
write it down for later transmission,
and James would return to Portsmouth
with no one aware that anything
significant had occurred.
After 3 weeks, he had delivered
intelligence on British troop strength,
approximately 4,000 regulars, 2,000
militia, 800 Hessians, fortification
plans, supply schedules, and officer
dynamics. Lafayette received the
information with growing appreciation.
His spy was exceeding all expectations.
But James was about to become even more
valuable. General Lord Charles
Cornwallis arrived in Portsmouth on May
20th, 1781,
and the entire British operation in
Virginia transformed. Cornwallis was
Britain's most experienced general in
America. a professional soldier who had
fought in Europe and India. A man who
understood war as a science rather than
a romantic adventure. He was also deeply
frustrated. For 6 years, Britain had
been fighting an enemy that refused to
fight conventionally. The Continental
Army avoided decisive battles, harassed
supply lines, melted into the
countryside when pressed. It was
guerilla warfare conducted by an enemy
that seemed to have infinite patience
and unlimited space to retreat into.
Cornwallis intended to change that. His
strategy was to establish a permanent
British presence in Virginia, the heart
of the rebellion, home to many
revolutionary leaders, and use it as a
base to finally crush continental
resistance. Portsouth would become his
fortress from which he could project
power throughout the region. His arrival
brought immediate changes. Discipline
tightened. Fortification work
accelerated. Patrols intensified. The
entire British presence became more
organized, more efficient, more
dangerous. And Cornwallis brought with
him a professional intelligence
apparatus. Captain Richard Durham was
Cornwallis's intelligence officer, a
veteran of multiple campaigns who
understood that information won wars as
surely as battlefield tactics. He was in
his late 30s, lean and sharpeyed with
the manner of someone who trusted no one
and suspected everyone.
Durham's first action was to review
existing intelligence gathering
operations. He questioned officers about
local informants, examined reports about
continental positions, assessed the
reliability of information sources, and
he recognized a significant gap. The
British had plenty of information from
loyalist civilians about continental
movements outside British controlled
territory, but relatively little
intelligence about continental
intentions, capabilities, and leadership
thinking. What Durham needed was someone
who could infiltrate continental lines,
gather information, and return safely.
He needed a spy. He began interviewing
the enslaved laborers who had fled to
British lines, looking for candidates
with the right combination of
intelligence, local knowledge, and
motivation. Most were unsuitable, too
obviously intelligent, which would make
Continental officers suspicious, or too
simple, which would limit their ability
to gather useful information. But one
interview stood out. James had been
working on fortification construction
for 6 weeks when he was pulled aside by
a sergeant and told to report to Captain
Durham's office. He felt a spike of
fear. Had something gone wrong? Had
someone become suspicious, but kept his
face neutral as he walked to the
requisitioned house that served as
British intelligence headquarters.
Durham received him in a small office
that smelled of pipe tobacco and paper.
The intelligence officer studied James
with the careful attention of someone
who made a profession of reading people.
Sit down.
James sat, keeping his posture
submissive but not cringing. You're
James. Came over from Armistad
Plantation 6 weeks ago. Yes, sir. You've
been a good worker. Supervisors say you
follow orders, don't cause trouble, seem
grateful for the opportunity to serve
his majesty. I am grateful, sir. Better
than being sold to Georgia. Durham lit
his pipe, using the action to study
James's face. You know this area well?
The roads, the plantations, the terrain?
Yes, sir. Lived here my whole life. Ran
errands between plantations before the
war. You ever see continental soldiers?
Sometimes, sir, when they'd pass through
the area. What did you think of them? It
was a test question. Assessing James's
attitudes, he answered carefully. Didn't
think much about them, sir. Masters
talked about politics, but that wasn't
my concern. I just tried to stay out of
trouble. Durham nodded, apparently
satisfied. I'm going to ask you
something, and I want an honest answer.
Would you be willing to return to rebel
controlled territory to gather
information for his majesty's forces?
James felt his heart race, but showed
only confused curiosity. Return there,
sir. How you'd approach Continental
lines with a story? Maybe that the
British weren't what you hoped. Maybe
that you want to return to familiar
territory. Maybe something else. You'd
gain their trust, observe their
positions and plans, then return here
with information. Durham watched him carefully.
carefully.
It would be dangerous. If they suspected
you, they'd hang you as a spy, but it
would strike a blow against the rebels
who kept you enslaved. James pretended
to think about this, letting concern
show on his face. I don't know, sir.
That sounds dangerous. What if they
recognize me? No, I ran to the British.
That's why it works. They'd expect a
runaway to be conflicted, possibly
wanting to return. Your honesty about
your situation would make you credible.
Durham leaned forward. Think about it.
The rebels talk about freedom while
keeping people like you in chains. The
British are actually offering you a
chance at liberty. Don't you want to
strike back at the system that enslaved
you? It was the perfect appeal. And
James responded to it with exactly the
right mixture of reluctance and growing
willingness. If you think I can help,
sir, if it means helping win the war and
getting my freedom, I suppose I could
try. Durham smiled, satisfied. Good man.
We'll prepare you carefully. This is
important work, James. His majesty will
remember your service. And just like
that, James Armiststead became a double
agent. Operating as a double agent
required mental gymnastics that
exhausted James in ways physical labor
never had. He was now maintaining three
separate identities simultaneously.
First, his surface identity as James,
the grateful runaway working for the
British, simple and loyal. Second, his
persona as a potential spy for the
British, being trained by Durham to
gather continental intelligence, still
playing simple and grateful, but showing
slightly more capability. Third, his
actual identity as Lafayette's
operative, using his British assignments
as cover to gather information about
British operations while feeding
carefully crafted misinformation back to
Durham. Durham spent two weeks training
James for his mission. The British
intelligence officer taught him what to
look for. Continental troop strengths,
artillery positions, supply situations,
officer morale. He taught him how to ask
questions without seeming obvious. how
to remember details, how to maintain his cover.
cover.
James absorbed the training while
carefully noting everything Durham
taught him. The training methods
themselves were intelligence. They
revealed what the British considered
important, what gaps existed in their
knowledge, what assumptions guided their
intelligence gathering. Durham also
prepared false intelligence for James to
discover and report back. This was
standard counter intelligence practice,
feeding your spy information you want
the enemy to believe, then having the
spy leak it as if revealing secrets. But
James understood exactly what was
happening. He mentally categorized the
false information Durham wanted planted,
knowing he would need to report it to
Lafayette's handlers so they could
assess British intentions. In midJune,
Durham decided James was ready. They
crafted a cover story. James would claim
he had left the British because
conditions weren't what he'd hoped, that
he missed familiar territory, that he
wanted to try returning to the Armistad
plantation to see if he could avoid
punishment. It was psychologically
plausible. Homesickness and regret were
common among runaways. When you reach
continental lines, they'll question you,
Durham instructed. Be honest about
coming from us. Lying about that would
be immediately suspicious. Say you're
disillusioned, that you realize the
rebels might win and you want to be on
the winning side. Show them you
understand the area, that you can be
useful. Then observe everything and
return within 2 weeks. Yes, sir. I'll do
my best. Durham handed him a pass that
would get him through British picket
lines. Good luck, James. His majesty's
cause depends on men like you. James
left Portsmouth on a June morning,
walking the same road he had approached
from two months earlier. But this time
he was carrying two sets of
intelligence, genuine British
information for Lafayette, and false
information Durham wanted fed to
Continental Command. The complexity was
staggering. He had to remember what the
British thought he believed, what he
actually knew, what he was supposed to
report, and what he needed to genuinely
report. A single mistake, a moment of
confusion that led to contradictory
information could expose him to either
side. He reached continental lines by midday.
midday.
American centuries stopped him, and he
gave his prepared story. He had run to
the British seeking freedom, found
conditions there difficult, was now
seeking to return to familiar territory,
and perhaps be useful to the continental
cause. The centuries were immediately
suspicious. a black man coming from
British lines could be a genuine
defector or a British spy. They held him
under guard while sending word up the
chain of command. Within hours, James
was being questioned by Continental
intelligence officers.
They interrogated him for the entire
afternoon. Where had he been? What had
he seen? Why was he returning? What did
he know about British positions? James
answered carefully, mixing truth with
strategic emissions.
Yes, he had been in Portsmouth. Yes, he
had worked for the British. Yes, he had
seen their fortifications and troop
positions. He described what he had
observed, providing accurate
intelligence that proved his credibility.
credibility.
But he didn't mention Lafayette or his
previous spy work. That information was
compartmentalized. Only specific
Continental officers knew about his
mission and he couldn't reveal it to
these interrogators without proper authentication.
authentication.
Finally, one of the officers said
something that contained a recognition
phrase Captain Haynes had taught him.
You seem like someone who pays attention
to details. James responded with the
counterphrase, "My mother always said
noticing things kept you alive." The
officer's demeanor immediately changed.
Wait here. An hour later, James was
taken to a private tent and reunited
with Captain Haynes. The intelligence
officer embraced him briefly, a rare
expression of warmth. Welcome back. We
were starting to worry. Durham recruited
you. Yes, sir. Trained me for 2 weeks.
Sent me here to gather intelligence on
your positions. Haynes grinned. Perfect.
Absolutely perfect. Now we can feed them
exactly what we want them to believe
while you gather genuine intelligence
from inside their command structure.
They spent the next several hours
debriefing. James reported everything he
had learned during his time in
Portsmouth. Troop strengths,
fortification layouts, supply schedules,
officer dynamics, Durham's intelligence
priorities. He also reported the false
information Durham had given him to
plant with Continental Command. Haynes
took careful notes, already planning how
to use this intelligence. You'll stay
here for a week. We'll carefully craft
information for you to take back to
Durham, mostly accurate, but with
strategic distortions. Then you return
to Portsmouth, report your intelligence,
and continue the cycle. They'll test me,
sir. Durham will ask questions designed
to catch inconsistencies. I know. That's
why we'll prepare your report
meticulously. Every detail has to be
consistent. verifiable where possible,
but misleading in aggregate. For the
next week, James worked with Continental
intelligence officers to prepare his
false report. They gave him information
about continental positions, mostly
accurate in detail, but strategically
misleading in implication.
Troop strengths were exaggerated.
Artillery positions were slightly mislocated.
mislocated.
Supply situations were described as
better than they actually were.
The goal was to make the British believe
Lafayette's forces were stronger and
better positioned than reality, which
would make Cornwallis more cautious,
possibly causing him to miss offensive opportunities.
opportunities.
But preparing this information required
James to memorize yet another version of
reality. He now had to remember what the
British had told him to look for, what
he had actually seen, what he was
reporting to Durham, and what the truth
actually was. Four different versions of
reality had to coexist in his mind
without getting confused. Lafayette met
with him before he returned to British
lines. The French general looked tired.
Weeks of maneuvering against superior
British forces had worn on him, but he
managed a smile when he saw James.
Captain Haynes tells me you've done
extraordinary work. Durham trusts you completely.
completely.
For now, sir, but how long can I keep
this up? Every time I cross lines, every
conversation, every report, one mistake
and I'm dead. Lafayette's expression
became serious. I know what I'm asking
of you. No one would blame you for
refusing to continue. But the
intelligence you're providing is
invaluable. You're giving us eyes inside
Cornwallis's headquarters. That
advantage could win us this campaign.
James thought about his mother, about
the promise of freedom, about the
possibility that this desperate gamble
might actually mean something. I'll
continue, sir, but I need to know. If we
win, will my service be remembered? Will
it count toward my freedom? I swear to
you, on my honor as a French nobleman, I
will do everything in my power to secure
your freedom. I will document your
service, testify before any authority
necessary, use every bit of influence I
possess. Lafayette gripped his shoulder.
You have my word. It would have to be
enough. James returned to British lines
the next day, carrying intelligence that
was simultaneously true and false,
playing a role that was simultaneously
sincere and deceptive. The double game
had truly begun. The next two months,
July and August 1781, were the most
dangerous period of James's life. He
crossed between Continental and British
lines six more times, each journey
carrying the risk of exposure, capture,
or death. The routine became grimly
familiar. He would spend 10 days to two
weeks with the British, working and
observing, gathering intelligence while
feeding Durham carefully prepared
reports about continental positions.
Then he would request permission to
return to rebel territory under various
pretexts, checking on family, seeking
additional intelligence, maintaining his
cover as someone conflicted about which
side to support.
Durham would brief him on what to look
for, sometimes giving him specific
questions to answer. Where was Lafayette
positioning his artillery? What were
continental supply situations? Were
reinforcements arriving from the north?
Each question revealed British
intelligence priorities and gaps. James
would cross to continental lines,
undergo debriefing with Haynes, deliver
his genuine British intelligence, and
receive carefully crafted false
information to report back. Then he
would return to Portsmouth, deliver his
false report, and begin the cycle again.
The strain was enormous. He had to
remember not just information, but the
context of information. What he was
supposed to have observed versus what he
had actually seen, what Durham expected
to hear versus what would be credible,
what the British believed versus what
Continental officers knew. Several times
he came dangerously close to exposure.
Once Durham questioned him about
Continental artillery positions. James
provided the false information he had
been given. six cannon on a ridge east
of Lafayette's encampment. But then
Durham produced a report from a loyalist
scout that contradicted his information.
This scout says there are no cannon on
that ridge. Either you're lying or
you're mistaken or he's incompetent.
James's mind raced, searching for an
explanation that would preserve his
cover. Sir, I saw supply wagons moving
toward that ridge and heard soldiers
talking about artillery placement. But
maybe they were moving the cannon, not
positioning them there. Or maybe the
scout observed a different ridge. Durham
stared at him for a long moment. James
kept his breathing steady, his
expression confused and worried. A
simple man concerned he'd made a
mistake, not a spy caught in a lie.
Finally, Durham nodded. Possibly. The
rebels do move their positions
frequently. Be more careful about your observations.
observations.
Yes, sir. I'm sorry, sir. Another time,
a British officer who had previously
interrogated James stopped him in
Portsmouth and asked casual questions
about his background. The questions
seemed friendly, conversational, but
James recognized them as an intelligence
test, verifying his story against
previous statements. You said you came
from Armistad plantation, right? Yes,
sir. How many slaves on that plantation?
James had never mentioned the specific
number before, but giving a vague answer
now would be suspicious. A man who grew
up on a plantation would know roughly
how many people lived there. Around 60,
sir. Maybe a few more or less depending
on births and who gets sold. And you
work the tobacco fields? Yes, sir.
tobacco, mostly some corn. Your master,
William Armistad, he married? Yes, sir.
Mrs. Armistad, and they got three
children, two boys and a girl. The
officer nodded, apparently satisfied.
But James' hands were shaking slightly
as he walked away. These casual
interrogations were designed to catch
spies who had memorized prepared
stories, but lacked genuine knowledge.
One wrong answer about verifiable
details could unravel everything. The
psychological toll was immense. James
began having nightmares. Confused dreams
where he couldn't remember which side he
was supposed to be working for. Where
officers from both armies questioned him
simultaneously, where he stood on a
gallows watching himself hang. He lost
weight despite adequate food. His hands
developed a slight tremor. The mask of
submission he wore became harder to
maintain because underneath it he was
exhausted, terrified, stretched beyond
any reasonable human limit. But he
continued because the intelligence he
was providing was changing the war.
Lafayette used James's information to
avoid British traps to position his
forces advantageously to strike at
vulnerable supply lines. Cornwallis,
receiving false intelligence through
Durham's spy network, made strategic
decisions based on inaccurate
information. He believed Lafayette
commanded nearly twice his actual
strength. He thought continental supply
lines were more robust than they were.
He positioned his forces to counter
threats that didn't exist while leaving
actual vulnerabilities exposed. In late
July, James overheard a conversation
between Cornwallis and his senior
officers that would prove decisive. They
were discussing where to establish a
permanent British base in Virginia.
Cornwallis wanted a deep water port with
naval access, strong defensive
positions, and proximity to interior
supply lines. Yorktown. Cornwallis
decided studying a map. The York River
provides naval access. The terrain is defensible, and we can fortify it
defensible, and we can fortify it sufficiently to hold against anything
sufficiently to hold against anything Lafayette can bring against us. James
Lafayette can bring against us. James memorized every word of the
memorized every word of the conversation. Understanding he had just
conversation. Understanding he had just learned Britain's strategic center of
learned Britain's strategic center of gravity in Virginia. He reported it to
gravity in Virginia. He reported it to Haynes within 3 days. The intelligence
Haynes within 3 days. The intelligence officer immediately recognized the
officer immediately recognized the significance. If Cornwallis concentrates
significance. If Cornwallis concentrates at Yorktown and fortifies it, he's
at Yorktown and fortifies it, he's making himself vulnerable to siege
making himself vulnerable to siege warfare. if we can block his naval
warfare. if we can block his naval escape route and bring enough forces to
escape route and bring enough forces to surround him. Haynes didn't finish the
surround him. Haynes didn't finish the sentence, but the implication was clear.
sentence, but the implication was clear. The intelligence was forwarded to
The intelligence was forwarded to Lafayette, who sent it north to General
Lafayette, who sent it north to General Washington. The seeds of the Yorktown
Washington. The seeds of the Yorktown campaign were being planted, and James
campaign were being planted, and James Armistad was the gardener. But he
Armistad was the gardener. But he couldn't see the larger picture. He only
couldn't see the larger picture. He only knew that he was walking a blad's edge,
knew that he was walking a blad's edge, that every day might be his last, that
that every day might be his last, that the weight of secrets he carried was
the weight of secrets he carried was crushing him. In mid- August, something
crushing him. In mid- August, something broke inside him. He was in Portsmouth
broke inside him. He was in Portsmouth working a construction detail when he
working a construction detail when he saw another hanging, a woman this time,
saw another hanging, a woman this time, an enslaved person who had tried to
an enslaved person who had tried to escape British lines and been caught.
escape British lines and been caught. The British made it a public execution
The British made it a public execution as a warning. James watched her die and
as a warning. James watched her die and something in him fractured. That could
something in him fractured. That could be him. Would be him eventually because
be him. Would be him eventually because no one could maintain this deception
no one could maintain this deception indefinitely. Sooner or later he would
indefinitely. Sooner or later he would make a mistake, contradict himself, be
make a mistake, contradict himself, be caught in a lie, and then he would hang
caught in a lie, and then he would hang just like her, and no one would remember
just like her, and no one would remember his name or his service. That night he
his name or his service. That night he met his continental contact, a free
met his continental contact, a free black farmer who operated a small plot
black farmer who operated a small plot outside Portsmouth. James delivered his
outside Portsmouth. James delivered his intelligence report mechanically, his
intelligence report mechanically, his voice flat. You all right? The contact
voice flat. You all right? The contact asked, concerned. No, I'm not all right.
asked, concerned. No, I'm not all right. I'm tired. I'm terrified. And I don't
I'm tired. I'm terrified. And I don't know how much longer I can do this. The
know how much longer I can do this. The general needs you. Just a bit longer.
general needs you. Just a bit longer. Everyone keeps saying that. Just a bit
Everyone keeps saying that. Just a bit longer. Just one more crossing. Just one
longer. Just one more crossing. Just one more report. James' voice was harsh with
more report. James' voice was harsh with suppressed emotion. When does it end?
suppressed emotion. When does it end? When do I get to stop being terrified
When do I get to stop being terrified every single moment? The contact had no
every single moment? The contact had no answer. He clasped James' shoulder
answer. He clasped James' shoulder briefly, a gesture of solidarity and
briefly, a gesture of solidarity and sympathy, then disappeared into the
sympathy, then disappeared into the darkness. James walked back to
darkness. James walked back to Portsmouth alone, understanding that he
Portsmouth alone, understanding that he was trapped in the role he had accepted.
was trapped in the role he had accepted. He couldn't stop now without abandoning
He couldn't stop now without abandoning the mission without wasting all the risk
the mission without wasting all the risk and suffering he had already endured. He
and suffering he had already endured. He was committed whether he wanted to be or
was committed whether he wanted to be or not. All he could do was survive one
not. All he could do was survive one more day and then another and hope that
more day and then another and hope that eventually the war would end before his
eventually the war would end before his luck ran out. What James didn't know,
luck ran out. What James didn't know, what he couldn't know because the
what he couldn't know because the information was compartmentalized at the
information was compartmentalized at the highest levels of command was that his
highest levels of command was that his intelligence was enabling one of the
intelligence was enabling one of the most audacious military operations of
most audacious military operations of the war. General George Washington,
the war. General George Washington, commanding Continental forces in New
commanding Continental forces in New York, had been planning a massive
York, had been planning a massive assault on British held New York City.
assault on British held New York City. But the intelligence coming from
But the intelligence coming from Virginia, from Lafayette's network,
Virginia, from Lafayette's network, primarily from James, revealed an
primarily from James, revealed an extraordinary opportunity. Cornwallis
extraordinary opportunity. Cornwallis was concentrating British forces at
was concentrating British forces at Yorktown. He was fortifying the
Yorktown. He was fortifying the position, clearly intending to make it
position, clearly intending to make it his permanent base. If the French fleet
his permanent base. If the French fleet could achieve temporary naval
could achieve temporary naval superiority in Chesapeake Bay, cutting
superiority in Chesapeake Bay, cutting off Cornwallis's sea escape route, and
off Cornwallis's sea escape route, and if American and French armies could
if American and French armies could march south quickly enough to surround
march south quickly enough to surround him before British reinforcements
him before British reinforcements arrived, the British general could be
arrived, the British general could be trapped. It was a massive gamble.
trapped. It was a massive gamble. Washington would have to march his army
Washington would have to march his army nearly 500 m south, maintaining secrecy
nearly 500 m south, maintaining secrecy to prevent the British in New York from
to prevent the British in New York from following or warning Cornwallis. The
following or warning Cornwallis. The French fleet commanded by Admiral
French fleet commanded by Admiral Degrass would have to sail from the
Degrass would have to sail from the Caribbean at exactly the right time to
Caribbean at exactly the right time to intercept British naval forces and
intercept British naval forces and Lafayette's small army in Virginia would
Lafayette's small army in Virginia would have to contain Cornwallis without
have to contain Cornwallis without revealing their weakness until the trap
revealing their weakness until the trap could be sprung. Everything depended on
could be sprung. Everything depended on timing, secrecy, and accurate
timing, secrecy, and accurate intelligence. James provided the latter.
intelligence. James provided the latter. Throughout August, he continued
Throughout August, he continued reporting on British fortification work
reporting on British fortification work at Yorktown, on Cornwallis's troop
at Yorktown, on Cornwallis's troop dispositions, on supply situations, on
dispositions, on supply situations, on naval schedules. Each piece of
naval schedules. Each piece of intelligence helped Washington and his
intelligence helped Washington and his French allies refine their plan.
French allies refine their plan. Meanwhile, James fed Durham false
Meanwhile, James fed Durham false information that reinforced British
information that reinforced British confidence. He reported that Lafayette
confidence. He reported that Lafayette was considering withdrawing northward to
was considering withdrawing northward to join Washington. He reported continental
join Washington. He reported continental supply problems and low morale. He
supply problems and low morale. He reported that French naval forces were
reported that French naval forces were concentrating in the Caribbean, not
concentrating in the Caribbean, not sailing toward Virginia. Durham believed
sailing toward Virginia. Durham believed it all because James had established
it all because James had established credibility through accurate reports
credibility through accurate reports about verifiable details. The British
about verifiable details. The British intelligence officer trusted his spy
intelligence officer trusted his spy completely, never suspecting that every
completely, never suspecting that every strategic assessment was carefully
strategic assessment was carefully crafted to mislead British command. In
crafted to mislead British command. In late August, Washington's army began its
late August, Washington's army began its march south. To maintain deception, they
march south. To maintain deception, they created the appearance of preparing to
created the appearance of preparing to attack New York, then suddenly pivoted
attack New York, then suddenly pivoted south, moving with speed that surprised
south, moving with speed that surprised even continental officers. The French
even continental officers. The French fleet under Admiral Degrass departed the
fleet under Admiral Degrass departed the Caribbean, sailing north toward
Caribbean, sailing north toward Chesapeake Bay. Lafayette's forces in
Chesapeake Bay. Lafayette's forces in Virginia began carefully maneuvering to
Virginia began carefully maneuvering to block Cornwallis's escape routes while
block Cornwallis's escape routes while appearing to avoid direct confrontation.
appearing to avoid direct confrontation. The trap was closing and Cornwallis
The trap was closing and Cornwallis didn't see it. James, still moving
didn't see it. James, still moving between camps, gathering intelligence,
between camps, gathering intelligence, feeding misinformation, had no idea that
feeding misinformation, had no idea that his work was enabling a decisive
his work was enabling a decisive campaign.
campaign. He only knew that Durham's questions
He only knew that Durham's questions were becoming more urgent, more
were becoming more urgent, more specific, that British officers seemed
specific, that British officers seemed increasingly concerned about continental
increasingly concerned about continental movements. On September 2nd, something
movements. On September 2nd, something changed dramatically. James was in
changed dramatically. James was in Portsmouth when word spread through
Portsmouth when word spread through British ranks. A massive French fleet
British ranks. A massive French fleet had arrived in Chesapeake Bay engaging
had arrived in Chesapeake Bay engaging British naval forces. The battle of the
British naval forces. The battle of the Chesapeake lasted 5 days. The French
Chesapeake lasted 5 days. The French fleet, superior in numbers and position,
fleet, superior in numbers and position, drove off British naval forces,
drove off British naval forces, establishing temporary control of the
establishing temporary control of the bay. Cornwallis's sea escape route was
bay. Cornwallis's sea escape route was cut. Panic rippled through British
cut. Panic rippled through British officers. Without naval superiority,
officers. Without naval superiority, they were vulnerable. But Cornwallis
they were vulnerable. But Cornwallis remained confident in his
remained confident in his fortifications.
fortifications. Yorktown was defensible against anything
Yorktown was defensible against anything Lafayette could bring against him.
Lafayette could bring against him. Except it wasn't just Lafayette anymore.
Except it wasn't just Lafayette anymore. On September 14th, advanced elements of
On September 14th, advanced elements of Washington's army arrived from the
Washington's army arrived from the north. On September 26th, the combined
north. On September 26th, the combined American and French forces, nearly
American and French forces, nearly 20,000 soldiers, surrounded Yorktown.
20,000 soldiers, surrounded Yorktown. Cornwallis was trapped in a siege with
Cornwallis was trapped in a siege with roughly 8,000 defenders facing an enemy
roughly 8,000 defenders facing an enemy three times his size. With no escape
three times his size. With no escape route and no realistic hope of relief,
route and no realistic hope of relief, James found himself trapped inside the
James found himself trapped inside the siege. Unable to cross lines anymore,
siege. Unable to cross lines anymore, his work as a double agent ended
his work as a double agent ended abruptly, replaced by the immediate
abruptly, replaced by the immediate danger of living inside a besieged
danger of living inside a besieged fortress being pounded by artillery. The
fortress being pounded by artillery. The siege of Yorktown transformed the town
siege of Yorktown transformed the town into a vision of hell that would haunt
into a vision of hell that would haunt James for the rest of his life. Though
James for the rest of his life. Though he had been trained to avoid graphic
he had been trained to avoid graphic details, the sheer scale of suffering
details, the sheer scale of suffering around him was inescapable. The
around him was inescapable. The bombardment began on October 9th, 1781.
bombardment began on October 9th, 1781. American and French artillery positions
American and French artillery positions carefully established over the previous
carefully established over the previous two weeks opened fire with devastating
two weeks opened fire with devastating effect. The sound was constant,
effect. The sound was constant, overwhelming, a thunder that made
overwhelming, a thunder that made thought difficult and sleep impossible.
thought difficult and sleep impossible. James worked with other laborers trying
James worked with other laborers trying to reinforce fortifications that
to reinforce fortifications that crumbled as fast as they could repair
crumbled as fast as they could repair them. Cannonballs tore through
them. Cannonballs tore through earthworks, exploded positions,
intelligence work, legislative petitions with detailed descriptions of his
with detailed descriptions of his espionage activities, military records
espionage activities, military records that mentioned him in passing. The
that mentioned him in passing. The evidence existed, waiting for someone to
evidence existed, waiting for someone to look. But for generations, no one
look. But for generations, no one looked, or if they looked, they didn't
looked, or if they looked, they didn't consider the information significant
consider the information significant enough to integrate into dominant
enough to integrate into dominant historical narratives. It wasn't until
historical narratives. It wasn't until the midentieth century as historians
the midentieth century as historians began excavating fuller, more
began excavating fuller, more complicated stories of the American
complicated stories of the American Revolution that James Armistad Lafayette
Revolution that James Armistad Lafayette slowly emerged from historical
slowly emerged from historical obscurity. Researchers found Lafayette's
obscurity. Researchers found Lafayette's testimonial letters and realized their
testimonial letters and realized their significance. They discovered the
significance. They discovered the legislative petitions and understood the
legislative petitions and understood the extraordinary story they told. They
extraordinary story they told. They pieced together intelligence reports and
pieced together intelligence reports and reconstructed the ark of James'
reconstructed the ark of James' espionage work. Slowly, painstakingly,
espionage work. Slowly, painstakingly, his story was recovered from the silence
his story was recovered from the silence that had buried it. A historical marker
that had buried it. A historical marker was erected in New Kent County in the
was erected in New Kent County in the 1970s. His name began appearing in
1970s. His name began appearing in textbooks, usually in sidebars or
textbooks, usually in sidebars or supplementary sections. Historians of
supplementary sections. Historians of African-American contributions to the
African-American contributions to the revolution started including him as a
revolution started including him as a central figure. In 2007, the United
central figure. In 2007, the United States Postal Service issued a
States Postal Service issued a commemorative stamp bearing his image
commemorative stamp bearing his image and honoring his service. These
and honoring his service. These recognitions came more than 175 years
recognitions came more than 175 years after his death. But they came. Yet even
after his death. But they came. Yet even now his story remains largely unknown to
now his story remains largely unknown to general American audiences. Ask most
general American audiences. Ask most people to name revolutionary war spies
people to name revolutionary war spies and they'll mention Nathan Hail. Ask
and they'll mention Nathan Hail. Ask them about intelligence operations at
them about intelligence operations at Yorktown and they'll credit unnamed
Yorktown and they'll credit unnamed Continental officers or good fortune.
Continental officers or good fortune. Few know James Armistad Lafayette's
Few know James Armistad Lafayette's name. Fewer still understand the full
name. Fewer still understand the full scope of his contribution. His grave
scope of his contribution. His grave remains unmarked, its exact location
remains unmarked, its exact location lost to time. The wooden cross that once
lost to time. The wooden cross that once stood over his burial site decayed
stood over his burial site decayed decades ago. The Virginia soil holds his
decades ago. The Virginia soil holds his bones somewhere near New Kent County,
bones somewhere near New Kent County, anonymous among thousands of other
anonymous among thousands of other unmarked graves. This is what historical
unmarked graves. This is what historical erasure looks like in practice. Not the
erasure looks like in practice. Not the complete disappearance of evidence, the
complete disappearance of evidence, the documents survive. The facts remain
documents survive. The facts remain accessible to anyone willing to search
accessible to anyone willing to search archives, but the exclusion from
archives, but the exclusion from collective memory, from national
collective memory, from national narrative, from the stories a society
narrative, from the stories a society tells itself about its past.
tells itself about its past. James Armistad Lafayette changed the
James Armistad Lafayette changed the course of American history. His
course of American history. His intelligence work directly contributed
intelligence work directly contributed to the victory at Yorktown, which
to the victory at Yorktown, which effectively secured American
effectively secured American independence. Without his contribution,
independence. Without his contribution, the war might have lasted years longer,
the war might have lasted years longer, might have ended differently, might have
might have ended differently, might have produced a different nation entirely,
produced a different nation entirely, and for two centuries, America forgot
and for two centuries, America forgot him. Erica. The silence speaks volumes
him. Erica. The silence speaks volumes about whose stories get remembered,
about whose stories get remembered, whose contributions get celebrated,
whose contributions get celebrated, whose names get carved into monuments.
whose names get carved into monuments. It reveals the mechanisms of historical
It reveals the mechanisms of historical memory, not objective recording of
memory, not objective recording of truth, but selective construction of
truth, but selective construction of narratives that serve present purposes.
narratives that serve present purposes. James lived 20 years enslaved, fought
James lived 20 years enslaved, fought for a freedom he was denied for six
for a freedom he was denied for six additional years, then spent 40 more
additional years, then spent 40 more years as a marginally free black man in
years as a marginally free black man in a society built on the bondage of people
a society built on the bondage of people who looked like him. He died without
who looked like him. He died without recognition, without honor, without his
recognition, without honor, without his name appearing in any history of the war
name appearing in any history of the war he helped win. But the documents
he helped win. But the documents remained. The truth persisted, waiting
remained. The truth persisted, waiting in archives, ready for anyone willing to
in archives, ready for anyone willing to look. And now finally we look, we
look. And now finally we look, we remember, we acknowledge what was done,
remember, we acknowledge what was done, what was given, what was stolen. James
what was given, what was stolen. James Armistad Lafayette, the spy who changed
Armistad Lafayette, the spy who changed America but was erased from history.
America but was erased from history. until now. Until this moment, when his
until now. Until this moment, when his story is told again, when his name is
story is told again, when his name is spoken again, when his contribution is
spoken again, when his contribution is finally, belatedly, inadequately
finally, belatedly, inadequately acknowledged, the soil of Virginia holds
acknowledged, the soil of Virginia holds his bone somewhere unmarked and
his bone somewhere unmarked and forgotten. But his story, his
forgotten. But his story, his extraordinary, tragic, essential story,
extraordinary, tragic, essential story, survives, and in that survival, there is
survives, and in that survival, there is a kind of justice, incomplete, but real.
a kind of justice, incomplete, but real. His name was James Armistad Lafayette.
His name was James Armistad Lafayette. He was a slave who became a spy who
He was a slave who became a spy who helped win a war for freedom he was
helped win a war for freedom he was denied. He deserved better than history
denied. He deserved better than history gave him. But at least now finally his
gave him. But at least now finally his story can be told.
Click on any text or timestamp to jump to that moment in the video
Share:
Most transcripts ready in under 5 seconds
One-Click Copy125+ LanguagesSearch ContentJump to Timestamps
Paste YouTube URL
Enter any YouTube video link to get the full transcript
Transcript Extraction Form
Most transcripts ready in under 5 seconds
Get Our Chrome Extension
Get transcripts instantly without leaving YouTube. Install our Chrome extension for one-click access to any video's transcript directly on the watch page.
