0:06 my dear students today I am going to
0:08 demonstrate an actual Genie which
0:09 happened last week at the Delhi
0:11 University College
0:15 a GD requires seven kind of people
0:19 which are initiative strong supporter
0:22 strong opposer harmonizer statistics
0:25 Master time keeper and summarizer
0:27 it's quite often the case that
0:29 timekeeper and statistic Masters are not
0:31 there because topic is so opaque so
0:33 obtuse that it's hard to know much about
0:37 it so let me demonstrate the various
0:39 rules that you can play during the next
0:41 10 minutes so here comes the tuning all
0:44 right students are you all ready yes sir
0:47 okay so it's a compulsory consensus to
0:49 GD if you don't have a consensus then
0:51 the whole group will get rejected
0:54 understood understood okay very good so
0:57 you have 10 minutes the topic given to
0:59 you Shahid students is
1:02 is online education better or offline
1:04 education better your 10 minute start now
1:11 good morning my friends my name is anshu
1:13 Bhatia and I'm a second year student
1:15 with your permission may I start the GD
1:17 is it okay thank you
1:19 my respected friends I welcome you all
1:21 to this extremely prestigious group
1:24 discussion of navra Corporation and the
1:26 topic given to us is is online education
1:30 better or offline now I believe that
1:32 it's an extremely pertinent Topic in our
1:34 country's social economic political
1:36 context and I'm also very sure that all
1:38 of you respected colleagues would have
1:41 very passionate news however time is
1:42 very limited we have been given 10
1:44 minutes by nobra and we have to come up
1:47 with a compulsory consensus so uh may I
1:49 propose that we do the comparison on
1:50 three things
1:53 number one cost effectiveness
1:56 number two learning Effectiveness and
1:58 number three the vast reach to the
2:00 poorest and the lowest part of our
2:03 society so do you all agree Mohan Radha
2:05 okay great so I think we'll proceed like
2:07 this Mary question can you start yeah sure
2:12 thank you so much for my birthday friend
2:14 so I believe the topic which has been
2:17 given to us is uh very relevant because
2:20 of the coronavirus it is very obvious
2:23 that the only and only future for our
2:25 country is online education a country of
2:28 140 crore online companies like buy
2:30 juice and Academy and various other like
2:32 physics Vala have shown that online
2:34 education has three advantages number
2:37 one it's extreme really cost competitive
2:40 a school fee which is 10 000 by juice is
2:42 giving it for 10 Rupees number two it's
2:44 also convenient in a school you have to
2:47 get up at seven o'clock be there whereas
2:48 at buy two zero Academy you can study at
2:50 11 o'clock 12 O'Clock three o'clock in
2:52 the morning as per your convenience it's
2:55 comfortable and number three it's easy
2:57 to repeat a teacher in a class will
2:59 sleep only once but a buy choose an
3:01 academy will speak again so I really
3:04 believe no no no no no no I don't agree
3:05 with you my friend I think you are
3:07 saying something which is very extreme I
3:09 agree with you to some extent that
3:11 online is good but then please remember
3:14 online disadvantages also do you think
3:16 the poor people in small villages have
3:19 computers laptop internet so we are
3:21 talking about our respected initiator
3:24 has given a criteria that how is it
3:26 going to lead to the masses so on
3:28 criteria number three there is a serious
3:31 problem because we don't expect the poor
3:32 people and the masses to have computer
3:34 and laptop so I believe that's a big disadvantage
3:36 disadvantage
3:38 thank you my friend I think both of you
3:40 have made very good observations and uh
3:44 thank you so I would like to present a
3:46 balanced view over here I sincerely
3:48 believe it's a mixed bag
3:50 on some points I agree with you that
3:53 online is definitely very convenient you
3:54 don't have to physically go to the
3:57 college or the school and you can see it
3:59 at your comfort but on the other hand I
4:01 believe here also he has a point for
4:03 either that as far as online is
4:05 concerned there is a problem of reach
4:08 however may I add a couple of more
4:11 points from my side I sincerely believe
4:14 that as coronavirus has shown there will
4:16 be future situations where there will be
4:18 lot of uncertainty so in these
4:20 uncertainties we would need a hybrid model
4:26 so may I propose because time is almost
4:28 over and we have three minutes left that
4:31 let the group recommend to the jury that
4:34 on one hand offline has some benefits on
4:36 the other hand online has some benefits
4:38 so no no I think my friend you are being
4:41 very diplomatic let me tell you that as
4:43 far as offline is concerned offline is
4:45 clearly Superior I think I was just
4:48 talking to Monica and Monica has also
4:51 similar thoughts over here that offline
4:53 allows us holistic growing
4:55 future needs leaders because most
4:57 operational jobs will go to computer
4:59 like chitty Robert of that Nikon so as
5:01 research by Harvard shows that future
5:03 will be divided into either computer or
5:06 Victor so how do we develop leadership
5:08 skill by dealing with people so online
5:12 is a very serious relies while it can be
5:15 a backup it cannot be a substitute so
5:16 I'd like to give three plus control of
5:23 [Music]
5:26 empathy and number three it gives us
5:27 discipline because we have to get up in
5:29 the morning go to the school deal with
5:31 people I don't believe that online is a
5:34 substitute I think my friends I strongly
5:35 opposal of opinion over here and I'll
5:38 request the group to agree that offline
5:42 is superior what's that God Theory comes
5:44 okay guys time is up only one minute to
5:47 summarize so miss minakshi you did not
5:49 speak what would you like to say please
5:51 say to the group don't look at the jury
5:54 never look at the jury okay sir I am
5:56 sorry actually sir I was very
6:01 attachment okay so set and my respective
6:04 jury members and my worthy colleagues we
6:06 had a wonderful discussion very
6:09 vivacious discussion however regrettably
6:11 the group discussion was non-conclusive
6:13 we couldn't come to a conclusion the
6:15 group was largely divided some group
6:17 members felt that online is superior
6:20 because it is cheaper it is convenient
6:24 and it has a far range so I use an
6:25 academy these companies have
6:27 demonstrated how masses can benefit
6:30 because of online education on the other
6:32 hand our friend over here Sohan Kumar
6:35 had a very strong view that offline is
6:37 definitely Superior because it builds
6:39 teacher empathy it builds leadership
6:42 skills it builds discipline so at the
6:44 end while the group was not very
6:46 conclusive may I recommend from my side
6:50 a short summary then going forward a
6:52 country like India needs a combination
6:55 because it's a mixed bag and a
6:58 coronavirus a Korea War a Russia War may
7:00 put physical education at risk so our
7:02 recommendation to the jury is three
7:05 things number one every education
7:07 institution should be ready with a
7:09 hybrid model predominant Focus must
7:12 remain offline but hybrid should not be
7:13 forgotten so maybe colleges can do four
7:16 one five one and similarly companies can
7:18 do also similar thing number two the
7:21 option of online must definitely be
7:22 there because there are many students
7:25 who cannot do it at the same time and
7:26 who are working so these working
7:29 students should have a chance to then
7:31 probably come late at the night and see
7:34 it at home and number three offline
7:37 Master focus more constructively on
7:39 holistic personality development
7:42 leadership skills communication skills
7:45 self-esteem discipline if we are able to
7:47 do that then I think our country India
7:49 can definitely attain the superpower
7:51 status that we so deserve to be so
7:54 respected sir and my worthy members I
7:56 thank you all and with those words be
7:58 cut through the GD
8:01 this is how a typical GD may happen
8:04 one version
8:07 the most important lesson
8:09 from this discussion Asia
8:11 I'm not cheating
8:14 most of the topics are either
8:17 controversial or their neutral topics
8:19 is Nollywood good maybe partially good
8:22 partially bad is social mediable
8:24 partially good partially bad Russia
8:27 versus USA is Russia good maybe a little
8:29 bit you will see good a little bit
8:33 bonus no absolute definition on these
8:35 kind of topics
8:38 so the winner in corporate TVs is
8:40 someone who has the art of giving
8:44 balanced views and be able to say Sir
8:46 both sides have plus one minus Bollywood
8:48 also has some pluses and some minuses
8:51 sir offline has some plus and some minus
8:54 do not come across as strongly
8:57 obinerated if you come across as very
8:59 surprised that Bollywood is very good
9:02 good good book or Bang Bang
9:04 the jury would end up having a
9:07 perceptuality this child is very
9:09 strongly obedient
9:13 and doesn't respect diverse ways
9:16 even though you succeeded at all the
9:18 criterias you were a loud person you
9:20 were fast speaker you voted to
9:23 three-point rules still you did not come
9:26 across as unbiased neutral
9:28 neutral
9:30 without any prejudice
9:33 so with those words I end this mock GD
9:35 by giving you the last three mantras
9:38 Mantra number one try to be an initiator
9:40 because it always helps but if you're
9:42 too nervous and you don't know about the
9:45 topic then wait for a few minutes
9:48 but within the first 30 to 40 percent to enter
9:49 enter
9:52 don't leave the slog bubbles for too late
10:04 and finally
10:07 the last rule is it's not just about
10:09 initiation try to remain continuously
10:12 participative so in a 10 minute GD speak
10:16 for maybe four times five times and
10:19 every time you open your mouth please
10:23 please please speak for minimum 30 to 40
10:26 seconds using the Thunder tripod speech
10:28 matter I love you all God bless you tarya
10:30 tarya
